Is Geography a Science?

Ever since Geography was recognised as a subject in the 19th century, geographers have strived to make geography a ‘scientific’ subject, acceptable in the eyes of academics, hence its foundation as a university discipline.

So, for many years geographers followed scientific methods, in order to shape geography into an academic subject, and recognised fully as a science. But has this been achieved?

The Penguin dictionary of geography defines science as “Knowledge gained by detailed observation by deduction of the laws governing changes and conditions and by testing these deductions by experiment.” (Clark 1998: 358) Whilst on the surface geography seems to fit this description, in truth this is merely the tip of the iceberg, it can be seen that there are elements pointing to geography being a science, but also elements pointing to the opposite viewpoint. This essay will include a multitude of sources relating to this subject, highlighting the indicators that geography is in fact a science, and also a variety of counterarguments to this point. However it is clear that due to the on going nature of the argument it is clear that there will be no definite answers provided, merely guides to what may be, and as such this answer can probably never be fully concluded.

Throughout history geographers have strived to have geography recognised as a science, as this was deemed necessary for it to be accepted in the eyes of academics worldwide. This tradition has carried on into modern day society, with geographers indicating that the subject is indeed a science. As we can see there have been many academic journals and books written about geography, and this status alone help to prove that geography is in fact a science. On the other hand other subjects that are widely regarded as sciences (such as chemistry, biology and physics) may contest this, and would argue that many of its scientific qualities are in fact taken from them, for example geography is strongly linked with biology in many areas. However this may further help to show geography’s scientific nature, as ideas are taken and used from other sciences, meaning that it to must be a science if it has taken from other scientific subjects.

Every self proclaimed geographer today will be able to tell you that he or she has something to do with data collection, and this can be a major indicator towards whether geography is indeed a science or not. For the most part physical geographers are involved with data collection of a Quantative nature, for example beach sediment samples or the measurement of rainfall in different areas. This on its own suggests that geography is a science, as this fulfils the “detailed observation” and “testing deductions by experiment” parts of the science definition (Clark 1998: 358). Also the data gathered is empirical, which is strong indicator of a scientific subject. However Geography also incorporates human elements, which traditionally use Qualitative data. As qualitative data is not numerical many people would not believe it to be scientific, hence showing that there are areas of geography which not everybody would call scientific. Even still all data collection in all forms can be seen to be scientific, as long as the ‘science’ is not only interested in empirical data, this therefore is another indicator that geography is indeed a science. However if data collection is all that is required for a subject to be scientific then there is little to stop any other subject being considered a science, as most areas of interest.

12
Liked it
12 Responses to “Is Geography a Science?”
  1. azim Says...

    On October 13, 2009 at 8:01 am

    yes geography is science


  2. none Says...

    On September 21, 2010 at 7:04 pm

    ya it is


  3. Thomas M. Says...

    On September 26, 2010 at 10:36 am

    It is 100% a science, and I have no idea why anyone would question that.


  4. Anushka Says...

    On October 20, 2010 at 12:58 am

    there are two type of geography: Physical and Human Geography…Physical Geography is 100% science but Human Geography is not…


  5. S Matthews Says...

    On October 30, 2010 at 5:35 pm

    Two questions that are of interest to me:

    1) Who is author Ben Williams and what is his academic/theoretical/occupational background?

    2) The essay cites several sources (like Castree, Chalmers and Feyerabends) but the essay as published here does not include the full reference list. Where is it?


  6. James Wright Says...

    On November 3, 2010 at 3:25 pm

    please could you give the full citation / reference of those whom you quoted. thank you


  7. Ben K Williams Says...

    On November 7, 2010 at 10:14 am

    Hi guys, in response to S Matthews, I have recently graduated from the university of Exeter with a Geography Bsc (Hons) degree, although this article was written in my first year, when it was set as a piece of work.

    In response to both S Matthews and James, I tried to include the reference list but I could not publish it along with the article for some reason, I think the automatic filtering the website puts on recognises the titles or the work elsewhere on the web and assumes its plagiarism? If you could send me your email I would be happy to provide a full reference list, i’m not sure if you can send me a message by clicking my name at the top of the page? As obviously it is not advisable to paste your email address on a public page.

    Hope this helps!
    Ben


  8. Azim Fauzi Says...

    On March 23, 2011 at 9:12 am

    basically geography renown as first science to descover earth and natural phenomenom.. So yes, geography is science.


  9. lamis Says...

    On September 19, 2011 at 8:12 am

    yes it is, because when you ask yourself questions about everything around you, its considred a science. we took it in class today.
    Reply to Thomas M.: Ken might’ve had a hw or something, because we take this at school, and my teacher took it in college too.


  10. anonymous Says...

    On March 9, 2012 at 5:36 am

    Biology, Chemistry and Physics are the only sciences.


  11. Taimur Says...

    On May 2, 2012 at 12:34 pm

    why biology,chemistry n phycis are only scince subject??


  12. kweleza Says...

    On June 2, 2012 at 1:22 pm

    geography is science because whithin geography we learn other disciple such as biology,chemstry as well physics


Post Comment
comments powered by Disqus